North Dakota Legislature

NACCHO and The Network for Public Health’s New Report Proposed Limits on Public Health Authority: Dangerous for Public Health, Highlights Proposed State Laws Detrimental to Public Health

May 28, 2021 | Theresa Spinner

“In recent months, at least 15 state legislatures have passed or are considering measures to limit severely the legal authority of public health agencies, and other states may consider such legislation in the future, hindering the ability of health departments to do their jobs and putting wide swaths of the public at risk.”

—Proposed legislation poses an immediate threat to life and health and has long-term ramifications —

Washington, DC, May 28, 2021 —On Tuesday, the National Association of County and City Health Officials (NACCHO) representing the country’s nearly 3,000 local health departments and The Network for Public Health Law released a new report, entitled Proposed Limits on Public Health Authority: Dangerous for Public Health.

The report highlights state-level efforts to roll back or severely limit the authority of public health agencies, which will impact their ability to protect the public from serious illness, injury, and death both during and long after the COVID-19 pandemic. In recent months, at least 15 state legislatures have passed or are considering measures to limit severely the legal authority of public health agencies, and other states may consider such legislation in the future, hindering the ability of health departments to do their jobs and putting wide swaths of the public at risk.

The report provides examples of laws that would:

  • Prohibit requiring masks in any situation, including cases of active tuberculosis. In North Dakota, a new law would remove the authority of the state health office to require face masks or covering.

  • Block the closure of businesses necessary to prevent the spread of disease, allowing for super spreader venues. In Kansas, a new law removes the Governor’s ability to close businesses during a public health emergency.

  • Ban the use of quarantine. In Montana, a new law prohibits local board of health emergency orders from separating those individuals who are not yet ill, but reasonably believed to be infected or exposed. Prohibition of quarantine orders undermines the basis of infection control and would make it impossible to stop outbreaks of deadly diseases that are spread by individuals who are not yet symptomatic.

  • Block state hospitals and universities from requiring vaccinations for employees and students in dormitories to protect state residents. In Arizona, a new law prohibits requirements that a person receive a vaccination, except in K-12 school settings and creates criminal penalties for violating the ban.

  • Strip local governments, including local health agencies, of the ability to respond to local conditions in an emergency. In Texas, a proposed bill would preempt local emergency action to the extent that it is inconsistent with orders of the Governor or state health department.

  • Set arbitrary time limit for emergency orders. In Florida, a new law provides for automatic expiration of local orders after seven days with a majority vote of the local governing body required for an extension, limits the total duration of local orders to 42 days, and prevents the issuance of a substantially similar order for the same emergency if a previous order has expired.

  • Give unilateral power to legislatures to stop public health actions. In Ohio, a new law will allow the legislature alone to rescind any order or action by the state health department or director of health to control or spread the spread of contagious or infectious disease. The Governor, who vetoed the law, issued a statement saying that the law “strikes at the heart of local health departments’ ability to move quickly to protect the public from the most serious emergencies Ohio could face.” The Governor’s veto was overridden by the legislature and the law will take effect June 23, 2021.

  • Legislation to block reasonable public health measures like mask wearing, social distancing, and quarantine poses an immediate threat to life and health.

  • Legislation to stop expert public health agencies from leading the response to health emergencies creates unforeseen, serious risks to life and health.

  • Legislation that strips authority from public health agencies and the executive branch infringes on the constitutional separation of powers and undermines effective government response.

  • These laws could make it harder to advance health equity during a pandemic that has disproportionately sickened and killed Black, Hispanic and Latino, and Indigenous Americans.

The report reaches four conclusions:

  1. Legislation to block reasonable public health measures like mask wearing, social distancing, and quarantine poses an immediate threat to life and health.
  2. Legislation to stop expert public health agencies from leading the response to health emergencies creates unforeseen, serious risks to life and health.
  3. Legislation that strips authority from public health agencies and the executive branch infringes on the constitutional separation of powers and undermines effective government response.
  4. These laws could make it harder to advance health equity during a pandemic that has disproportionately sickened and killed Black, Hispanic and Latino, and Indigenous Americans.

###

About NACCHO
The National Association of County and City Health Officials (NACCHO) represents the nation’s nearly 3,000 local governmental health departments. These city, county, metropolitan, district, and tribal departments work every day to protect and promote health and well-being for all people in their communities. For more information about NACCHO, please visit www.naccho.org.

About the Network for Public Health Law

The Network provides visionary leadership in the use of law to promote, protect and improve health and advance health equity. The Network works with local, tribal, state and federal public health officials and practitioners, as well as attorneys, policymakers, advocates, and community organizations, providing information, resources, consultation and training. Visit networkforphl.org.


National association of county and city health officials naccho squarelogo

About Theresa Spinner

Theresa Spinner is the Director, Media and Public Relations at NACCHO.

More posts by Theresa Spinner

Related Posts

Capitol Close Up Dome
  • Immunization

House Energy and Commerce Health Subcommittee Holds...

On Tuesday, June 15, The House Energy and Commerce Subcommittee on...

Jun 17, 2021 | Cameron Etessami

House Energy and Commerce Health Subcommittee Holds...

US Washington Capitol

President Biden’s First Full Budget Proposal

A deeper look into President Biden’s FY2022 budget request to Congress.

Jun 14, 2021 | Ian Goldstein

President Biden’s First Full Budget Proposal

US Washington Capitol

Senate Appropriations Subcommittee Talks Budget...

On Thursday, June 10, the Senate Appropriations Subcommittee on Agriculture,...

Jun 11, 2021 | Silvio Renna

Senate Appropriations Subcommittee Talks Budget...

Capitol Dome with Mic typeface display V3
  • Podcast

Podcast from Washington: CDC HIV Programs, Local to...

Ian Goldstein talks with Jonathan Hanft, Ryan White Program Coordinator for...

Jun 11, 2021 | Ian Goldstein

Podcast from Washington: CDC HIV Programs, Local to...

Capitol Dome with Mic typeface display V3
  • Podcast

Podcast from Washington - Vaccinating the 12 - 15 year...

Ian Goldstein talks with Dr. Ying Ying Goh, Director and Health Officer of the...

Jun 01, 2021 | Ian Goldstein

Podcast from Washington - Vaccinating the 12 - 15 year...

Cdcdirector 1200px
  • Workforce Development

House Appropriations Subcommittee Holds Hearing with CDC...

On May 26, the House Appropriations Subcommittee on Labor, Health and Human...

May 28, 2021 | Cameron Etessami

House Appropriations Subcommittee Holds Hearing with CDC...

Shelton Karen
  • Workforce Development

NACCHO Member Testifies Before Congressional Committee

NACCHO member Dr. Karen Shelton testified before the House Energy and Commerce...

May 27, 2021 | Cameron Etessami

NACCHO Member Testifies Before Congressional Committee

Covid 19 Person
  • Press Release

NACCHO Member Karen Shelton, MD, FACOG, Southwest...

Tomorrow, Karen Shelton, MD, FACOG, Director of the Mount Rogers Health...

May 25, 2021 | Theresa Spinner

NACCHO Member Karen Shelton, MD, FACOG, Southwest...

Cdcdirector 1200px
  • COVID-19

Senate Appropriations Subcommittee Holds Hearing with...

On May 19, the Senate Appropriations Subcommittee on Labor, Health and Human...

May 19, 2021 | Cameron Etessami

Senate Appropriations Subcommittee Holds Hearing with...

Back to Top