NACCHO’s 2013 National Profile of Local Health Departments Shows Continued Funding Cuts for Preparedness

Jan 28, 2014 | Frances Bevington

By Frances Bevington, Senior Marketing and Communications Specialist and Stacy Stanford, MSPH, Program Analyst; Public Health Preparedness, NACCHO

On Jan. 21, NACCHO released the report of findings and data from the 2013 National Profile of Local Health Departments (Profile) study, demonstrating continued funding cuts across several programmatic areas at local health departments (LHDs), including emergency preparedness. According to NACCHO staff Carolyn Leep, Senior Director of Research and Evaluation, and Jan Wilhoit, Senior Project Management Specialist for the Profile, funding for emergency preparedness, particularly per capita funding, saw a significant drop in 2013, with LHDs reporting median per capita funding of $1.15 in 2013 compared to $2.07 per capita in 2010. This finding is consistent with continued decreases in overall federal funding for emergency preparedness, which has dropped more than 25 percent since 2007.

2014Profile_PerCapita

What is striking about the decrease in emergency preparedness funding is that LHDs are not reporting a corresponding decrease in staff. In fact, LHDs have increased emergency preparedness staff with 77 percent of all LHDs reporting a full time equivalent (FTE) in 2013, compared with 65 percent of all LHDs in 2010. Nationally, the number of emergency preparedness staff employed by LHDs grew to an estimated 2,900 FTEs in 2013 from 2,700 in 2010, an increase of approximately seven percent. While NACCHO has interviewed members who have anecdotally reported that decreases in funding have led to decreases in trainings, exercises, travel, and supplies because cuts in these areas precede staffing cuts, further research is needed to understand the full implications of funding cuts in emergency preparedness at the local level. Other findings of note regarding emergency preparedness include the following:

  • Most LHDs have developed or updated a written emergency plan (87%) or provided emergency preparedness training to staff (84%).
  • Since September 2010, more than half of all LHDs (55%) have responded to at least one all-hazards event, and almost all (93%) have participated in an emergency response drill or exercise.
  • Natural disasters are the most common all-hazards event LHDs have responded to since September 2010 (41%), followed by an influenza outbreak (30%) and an outbreak of other infectious diseases (27%).
  • LHDs also prepare for rare events; for example, few LHDs (6%) have responded to an exposure to a potential biological agent since September 2010, but 35 percent of LHDs have participated in drills/exercises to prepare for such an event.

Several findings that describe the overall state of personnel and practices at LHDs could have implications for emergency preparedness programs. For example, Profile data demonstrated a long-term decrease in LHD staff dating to the enactment of broad federal funding cuts in 2008. The total number of individuals employed at LHDs in 2013 was 162,000 as compared to 190,000 in 2008 and nearly one-half (48%) of all LHDs reduced or eliminated services in at least one program area. Less staff overall would likely result in less staff to respond to emergencies, regardless of whether or not those staff are emergency preparedness personnel. Findings also show that the top agency executives at LHDs are aging, with 25 percent of top executives over the age of 60 compared to 16 percent in 2005. As these top executives reach retirement age, knowledge acquired through responses to past emergencies may be lost. Also of note is the increasing level of LHDs who are engaging in formal quality improvement (QI) activities, most often in specific program areas, with 56 percent reporting a formal QI program compared to 45 percent in 2010. Participation in programs that emphasize quality improvement, such as NACCHO’s Project Public Health Ready, may be contributing to this increase.

NACCHO supports the Medical Reserve Corps (MRC), a national network of more than 200,000 volunteers in nearly 1,000 local units, through a cooperative agreement with the U.S. Department of Health and Human Services’ Office of the Surgeon General and encourages LHDs to engage MRC units in emergency preparedness activities. The 2013 Profile findings indicated that while only 16 percent of LHDs reported no engagement with volunteers, only 27 percent engage MRC volunteers specifically. This suggests that there is potential for increased collaboration between LHDs and MRC units. NACCHO is authoring a similar study of the MRC network that will be released in March 2014, “The 2013 Network Profile of the Medical Reserve Corps.” This study may offer LHDs more insight into how to best to engage with MRC units and volunteers.

2014Profile_Volunteers

The 2013 Profile expanded and added questions to measure changing practices at LHDs. The new data offer insights into policy activities that could be the first national-level data available on the policy work of LHDs. Most LHDs (90%) have been involved in some policy or advocacy areas in the past two years with 58 percent engaging in policy or advocacy specifically about emergency preparedness and response. The Profile also expanded the data collected about social media use at LHDs and found that, while LHDs are comparatively late adopters of social media, social media use is steadily increasing with 44 percent using Facebook in 2013 compared to 26 percent in 2010. The use of YouTube increased to 12 percent from six percent in 2010 and the use of Twitter increased to 18 percent from 13 percent in 2010. The 2013 Profile also asked about the use of social media for surveillance activities for the first time with results showing that ten percent of LHDs report this type of activity. However, the results are heavily skewed toward large LHDs that may have more resources and staff available for such activities. Profile data also show that large health departments serving populations greater than 500,000 are much more likely to have a Public Information Officer FTE, which recent research suggests may be correlated with capacity for social media activity. [1]

NACCHO has been collecting data through the Profile to inform a comprehensive picture of infrastructure and practice at LHDs since 1989. The 2013 Profile is the seventh version of this study and includes a collection of descriptive statistics of 2,000 respondents that is representative of the nation’s approximately 2,800 LHDs. For the study, an LHD is defined as an administrative or service unit of local or state government, concerned with health, and carrying some responsibility for the health of a jurisdiction smaller than the state. The study provides a fundamental basis for research on LHDs and represents a major investment of time on behalf of the LHDs who complete the Profile and a significant contribution by these LHDs to the knowledge base of public health.

What have been the consequences of cuts in preparedness funding to your LHD? Let us know in the comment section below.

  1. Harris, J., Choucair, B., Maier, R., Jolani, N., Bernhardt, J. (under review). Are public health organizations tweeting to the choir? Understanding LHD Twitter followership.


About Frances Bevington

More posts by Frances Bevington

Related Posts

I Stock 1406072634
  • Community Health Emergency Response Health & Disability

Addressing the Needs of People with Disabilities in...

Addressing the needs of people with disabilities in local preparedness...

Jul 19, 2024 | Uyen Tran

Addressing the Needs of People with Disabilities in...

FCN taking B Ps web
  • Medical Reserve Corps

Partnering with Faith Communities to Provide Health...

See how this Ohio Medical Reserve Corps unit partners with churches to offer...

Jul 17, 2024 | Beth Hess

Partnering with Faith Communities to Provide Health...

  • HIV, STI, & Viral Hepatitis HIV, STI, Viral Hepatitis, and Harm Reduction Digest

Digest (July 17, 2024)

HIV, STI, Viral Hepatitis, and Harm Reduction Digest: July 17, 2024

Jul 17, 2024

Digest (July 17, 2024)

UMN CHW Toolkit 2024 Page 01 v2
  • Tools & Resources Community Health Performance Improvement Training

New Resources: Health Equity Performance Measures and...

NACCHO and CPHS create resources to support health equity and community health...

Jul 17, 2024 | Glenda Young- Marquez

New Resources: Health Equity Performance Measures and...

Untitled
  • Performance Improvement Research & Reports Workforce Development

Modernizing Public Health: Insights into Local Health...

Strong public health data, informatics, and analytics are vital to local health...

Jul 16, 2024 | Krishna Patel, DrPH, Kellie Hall, MS, and Meghan Shea, MPH

Modernizing Public Health: Insights into Local Health...

  • HIV, STI, & Viral Hepatitis

NACCHO Applauds FDA Approval of First Point-of-Care RNA...

On June 27, the US Food and Drug Administration (FDA) approved the first-ever...

Jul 16, 2024 | Kat Kelley

NACCHO Applauds FDA Approval of First Point-of-Care RNA...

I Stock 1319087136

Fighting the Rising Tides of Vaccine Hesitancy Among...

In the Spring of 2024, the Wyandotte County Health Department completed a rapid...

Jul 15, 2024 | Hannah Conner

Fighting the Rising Tides of Vaccine Hesitancy Among...

Climate Ready Workforce web
  • Tools & Resources Climate Change Rural and Frontier Health Rural Health

New Guide to Building a Climate-Ready Rural Workforce

Practical guide supports rural health departments in their efforts to build a...

Jul 15, 2024 | Nikita Kheni

New Guide to Building a Climate-Ready Rural Workforce

Capitol Bulding

House Appropriations Committee Passes FY25 Labor-HHS Bill

Coverage of the FY25 House Appropriations Committee Labor-HHS funding bill

Jul 12, 2024 | Victoria Van de Vate, Lauren Mastroberardino, Molly Curington

House Appropriations Committee Passes FY25 Labor-HHS Bill

Back to Top