Adaptive leadership 675 X400

Thoughts on Adaptive Leadership During the COVID-19 Pandemic

Apr 03, 2020 | Guest Author

This article was originally posted on JPHMP Direct.

By Edward L. Baker MD, MPH; Robert Irwin, MA; and Gene Matthews, JD

As public health leaders around the globe work to provide leadership in these challenging times, each day will present new or recurring leadership challenges. Some lessons learned from prior outbreaks may serve as useful guideposts. However, the coronavirus outbreak has, in important respects, presented unprecedented challenges. Therefore, leaders will draw on wisdom from prior experiences while learning, in real time, lessons from today.

In this post, we suggest that, by focusing on a few elements of leadership practice, public health leaders, particularly those in state and local health agencies, may find ways to prioritize actions and thereby better serve those in our communities through a greater clarity of mission and purpose. We also suggest leaders should consider the practices of adaptive leadership as offered by Heifetz, Linsky, and colleagues as they deal with challenges that are not clear-cut or easy to identify. They offer a set of practices (below) which may be helpful including “maintaining disciplined attention.”

Adaptive Leadership – Leader Behaviors

  1. Get on the Balcony
  2. Identify the Adaptive Challenge
  3. Regulate Distress
  4. Maintain disciplined attention
  5. Give the Work Back to the People
  6. Protect Leadership Voices from Below

One aspect of adaptive public health leadership is for leaders to focus attention (their own and that of others) on 4 central elements of leadership practice in these times. Although these 4 areas may not include everything to be considered, we submit these as a starting point to be used to structure consideration of a range of issues. These elements are 1) situational awareness, 2) decision making, 3) communication, and 4) energy. In each area, we suggest that leaders should focus on asking the right questions rather than having all the answers*.

*Baker EL, Gilkey R. Asking Better Questions – A Core Leadership Skill. J Public Health Management and Practice. In press. 2020.

Situational Awareness
Public health epidemiologists are schooled in the techniques of monitoring case counts, risk factors and other aspects of monitoring the course of a disease outbreak. All of this is critical to the process of framing the response. In addition to the epidemiologic approach to situational awareness, there are other components of situational awareness.

First, monitoring the status of the public health system at the local, state and national levels is critical. For example, the state of laboratory capacity across the nation has received laser-like attention. Other aspects of the public health system that are central to this response includes public health agency informatics capacity and communication capacity, particularly at the local and state levels. Thus, situational awareness should include monitoring of key system status indicators, such as the 10 Essential Public Health Services, as a component of situational awareness.

Further, as public health and the healthcare system work together in these times, public health agencies will need to enhance awareness of the status of capacity in health care facilities. As capacity evolves over coming weeks, public health leaders will be called on to address conditions and concerns regarding health care delivery. Thus, a greater awareness of health care system capacity will be needed.

So, in these times, situational awareness for public health leaders may be enhanced by focusing on a few questions:

  • What is the status of the coronavirus epidemic from an epidemiologic perspective?
  • What is the state of the public health system’s capacity and capability to respond to the epidemic?
  • What is the capacity of the health care system (especially at the community level) to provide needed care?
  • In a state or local health agency, what are other state or local government agencies doing?

Decision Making

In times of stress, the process of sound decision making can suffer. A preoccupation with events may lead to a short-term focus and a reactive posture.

All too often the process of decision making may concentrate exclusively on data (which changes hourly) and recent events (another type of data). As a result, leaders fail to take a longer view and adopt a broader perspective incorporating not only data, information, and knowledge, but also cultivating wisdom.

So, how might public health leaders expand the decision-making process and make wiser decisions? A few questions may be of value:

  • How is our prevailing mindset interfering with our ability to both question our assumptions and encourage alternative perspectives?
  • In what ways are we fostering systems and procedures to better “look around corners” and anticipate events more effectively?
  • How are we encouraging a few wise individuals to serve as “participant observers” to “get on the balcony” and observe our decision-making processes and provide real time feedback?
  • How are we seeking to uncover what we don’t know and also identify what may be unknowable?

Communication
Communication has now become the central science/tool of public health practice (in contrast to the central role of epidemiology in the past). In these times particularly, local public health leaders serve as a credible and trusted voice to address the needs of the public for meaningful, empathetic, consistent, and factual communications. A few questions may be useful:

As I communicate with others (my staff, my colleagues, local elected officials, and the public), what do they really need to hear? This question contrasts with the frequent mindset which asks:

  • “What do I need to say?”
  • Am I then tailoring communication to meet the specific needs of the audience?
  • What is the strategic intent of our communication?
  • How is my communication helping to prepare others for what lies ahead?

Read more on JPHMP Direct.


NACCHO logo small version02 square N pms321

About Guest Author

NACCHO periodically invites guest authors to write first-person accounts of their work in public health. To submit your own story for consideration, please visit our form.

More posts by Guest Author

Related Posts

I Stock 498649859
  • Funding Opportunity Health Equity & Social Justice

Request for Proposals: Website Developer for Health...

NACCHO is seeking a consultant to develop a dynamic website for NACCHO’s...

Apr 17, 2024 | Andrea Grenadier

Request for Proposals: Website Developer for Health...

NAACHO Infographic1
  • Community Health Community Resilience COVID-19 Performance Improvement

COVID Workforce Project Infographics

Check out infographics designed as part of an initiative to highlight the...

Apr 11, 2024 | Andrea Grenadier

COVID Workforce Project Infographics

NAACHO Full Page Greene jpg Page 1
  • Community Health Community Resilience COVID-19 Performance Improvement

Listening to the Community and Co-creating Solutions...

Fewer than 12k people call rural Greene County home. It may be a small...

Apr 11, 2024 | Andrea Grenadier

Listening to the Community and Co-creating Solutions...

NAACHO Full Page Lewis Page 1
  • Community Health Community Resilience COVID-19 Performance Improvement

Building on Personal Relationships to Serve the...

Lewis County, KY, stretches across nearly 500 square miles of wooded hills and...

Apr 11, 2024 | Andrea Grenadier

Building on Personal Relationships to Serve the...

NAACHO Full Page Marietta Belpre Page 1
  • Community Health Community Resilience COVID-19 Performance Improvement

Carrying Forward Lessons Learned from the COVID-19...

Marietta/Belpre Health Department serves a rural population of roughly 20k...

Apr 11, 2024 | Andrea Grenadier

Carrying Forward Lessons Learned from the COVID-19...

NAACHO Full Page Tuscarawas Page 1
  • Community Health Community Resilience COVID-19 Performance Improvement

Identifying Partners to Reach Residents During the...

Tuscarawas County Health Department serves a population in the Appalachia...

Apr 11, 2024 | Andrea Grenadier

Identifying Partners to Reach Residents During the...

NAACHO Full Page Oneida Page 1
  • Community Health Community Resilience COVID-19 Performance Improvement

NACCHO’s COVID Workforce Project: Leveraging Community...

At Oneida County Health Department, cooperation is baked into daily operations;...

Apr 11, 2024 | Andrea Grenadier

NACCHO’s COVID Workforce Project: Leveraging Community...

I Stock 1128971953
  • Funding Opportunity Healthy People 2030

Grant Announcement: Community Level Innovations for...

The Office of Minority Health at the U.S. Department of Health and Human...

Apr 03, 2024 | Andrea Grenadier

Grant Announcement: Community Level Innovations for...

I Stock 1348095101
  • Funding Opportunity Health Equity & Social Justice Opportunity Performance Improvement

DEADLINE EXTENDED: Request for Applications: Building...

This opportunity is designed to provide funding and capacity-building training,...

Mar 29, 2024 | Andrea Grenadier

DEADLINE EXTENDED: Request for Applications: Building...

Back to Top